Size of the Problem Lesson and Activity

size of the problem lesson

I don’t usually start the year off with a traditional “meet the counselor” lesson but I do have a lesson I love to use as my first of the new school year. My kickoff lesson for 3rd grade two years in a row now is to incorporate a size of the problem lesson. It sets us up well for our conflict resolution and problem solving theme and is the perfect opening for me teaching them how to appropriately self-refer to me.

The first thing we do is play a round of “Pass the Cat” (like hot potato) using Felix the Feelings Cat (a kimochi doll I have that has a belly pocket). Inside the belly pocket are some basic questions reviewing the role of the school counselor. Most of them were at my school last year and had my amazing co-counselor, but I like to do a short review for new students and to give me a jump start in learning names.

Using a stuffed animal I call Felix the Feeling Cat to review the role of school counselors and how students can self refer.

Weather Problem Sizes

Then we start our size of the problem lesson. I send them back to their desks and ask

“What if I told you that this morning I spilled my milk all over my floor – that would be a problem, right? Well what if I told you that I woke up this morning and my house had flooded – that would be the same, right? Or are they different sizes of problems?”

I then have them brainstorm with me about weather analogies for problems starting with the biggest (I’m shooting for tornado but this year’s weather-savvy cohort also gave me hurricane, tsunami, and earthquake), medium (thunderstorm), small (rain), and tiny (windy or cloudy). I draw these on the board as we go to help them remember, because I believe in visual learning, and to help out the big chunk of my friends that are ELL. To get down with our kinesthetic side, we also come up with a hand motion for each of the four sizes.

Practicing Identifying Problem Sizes

Every student is then given a problem. They are all real problems my 3rd graders have had over the years and they range drastically in size. I give them a minute to read it to themselves and then ask them to leave their desks and group themselves by what size problem they have and encourage them to use their hand signals. *At this point I get a clump of kiddos who have no idea what size to go with. I encourage them to ask a classmate*

size of the problem lesson

Once in position, I put a visual card on the floor by each group and have them place their problem cards around it. We then do a gallery walk: they walk silently through each of the four weather stations and read the problems. We get back together and I ask if they all seemed correct or if they would make some changes – no surprise, lots of changes needed.

Then they move the cards if they think they are actually smaller or bigger AND if they can find two classmates that agree with them. Magically, even though some problem cards get moved a gazillion times during these 5 minutes, my classes all seemed to get them much closer to accurate.

size of the problem lesson

Depending on time on their accuracy, I might project the problems one by one quickly on the document camera and answer any questions or explain why they were terribly wrong (The biggest error? Putting problems like “Someone gave you a mean look” in thunderstorm). We talk about which size problems they can handle on their own and which require an adult’s help.

With Younger Students

After the first year, I also started doing this lesson in 2nd grade in August. They needed some additional scaffolding on the skill itself (identifying size of the problem) and there were lots of pre-readers at the start of the year. For them, I created an animated slideshow.

The first part of the lesson goes through the different sizes of problems. We created hand motions and did some call and repeat for this part (eg. hands on hips for “I can be a problem solver”). Then we went through several problem examples together. I designated each corner of the room a specific problem size again and they would walk to an area to show their answer.

size of the problem lesson

This size of the problem lesson leads perfectly into my explaining the self-referral process and my “Let’s Talk” self-referral forms. We go through each component of it. I give an extra high-five and “kiss your brain” to the kiddo that can explain why I don’t put “windy” as an option!


Pin for later:

size of the problem lesson

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

I accept the Privacy Policy

Hello, I’m Sara!

With 10 years of experience in
elementary school counseling,
I get to serve in a different way now
– by helping fellow counselors and

I value quality over quantity,
effective practices and resources,
and meeting the unique needs of all
our diverse learners.

Have a question?

I’d be happy to answer any questions you have.  Just fill out the form below.


the doors to your counseling compass open soon!